Thoughts From the Divide: Avoiding the Inverse

Along with the release of the January Fed minutes this week, there was a deluge of Fed Speak, with Jefferson, Harker, Waller, and Cook all opining on the outlook for cuts. Most of the refrain was along the lines of Powell’s need for “confidence”, with Waller saying that he needed “to see at least another couple more months of inflation data” and Cook echoing the idea, saying that “as we gain greater confidence that disinflation is ongoing and sustainable, that changing outlook will warrant a change in the policy rate”. Harker pushed back on immediate cuts, asking for markets to “just give us a couple of meetings”, following up by saying, “I would caution anyone from looking for it right now and right away”. But while there may be some pushback on timing, that cuts are coming appears to be very much fait accompli in the mind of the Fed.
BY JON WEBB

Thoughts From the Divide: Avoiding the Inverse

February 23, 2024

“The possibility that past relationships in the economy no longer hold”

Along with the release of the January Fed minutes this week, there was a deluge of Fed Speak, with Jefferson, Harker, Waller, and Cook all opining on the outlook for cuts. Most of the refrain was along the lines of Powell’s need for “confidence”, with Waller saying that he needed “to see at least another couple more months of inflation data” and Cook echoing the idea, saying that “as we gain greater confidence that disinflation is ongoing and sustainable, that changing outlook will warrant a change in the policy rate”. Harker pushed back on immediate cuts, asking for markets to “just give us a couple of meetings”, following up by saying, “I would caution anyone from looking for it right now and right away”. But while there may be some pushback on timing, that cuts are coming appears to be very much fait accompli in the mind of the Fed. Jefferson described the timetable as later this year, and his speech on Monetary Policy Cycles was, “for exposition purposes”, focused “on easing cycles and their preceding peak-rate episodes”. Nudge, nudge, wink, wink.

As to Jefferson’s conclusions, Nick Timiraos took away that PCE “is not particularly elevated” compared to previous cycles and that “cuts without growth scares are very rare” but occasionally do happen, with 1995 as an example, which “could be a template for the type of cuts envisioned in the most recent SEP”. At the risk of tooting our own horn, we recommend those interested in the dynamics of past cycles watch or listen to Julian’s recent interview with Resolve Asset Management, which can be found here. This does of course come as PPI handily beat expectations, jobless claims were below forecasts, and the NAHB survey (of a “rate-sensitive” sector) also saw Builder Confidence continue its rise.

All of that said, a comment that stuck out from the Vice Chair’s Q&A session was his assertion that “whenever you have a[n] unusual event, there’s the possibility that past relationships in the economy will no longer hold… there can be structural changes or changes in the way… certain markets operate”. A little bit of wishful thinking, and some hope that while “a rising tide lifts all boats”, the inverse won’t be true?

https://www.gocomics.com/calvinandhobbes/1986/11/26

P.S. Though Nvidia’s stock may be on a trajectory similar to the Odysseus moon lander, the inverse of lower interest expenses and corporate tax rates could “mechanically” lead to “significantly lower profit growth and stock returns”.

P.P.S. Another inverse that may be on the radar of economic policy makers is Bernanke’s Savings Glut. While not necessarily a short-term question, what happens if some of the money stays home?

Other posts

Thoughts From The Divide: Finding Reasons

BY JON WEBB
The latest flurry of Fed speak has been a broad recanting of the previously guaranteed, 100% for sure, cuts this year, with members saying, “I definitely don’t feel urgency to cut rates”, “I’m not in a mad dash hurry to get there[, to lower rates]”, and “at some point, … we will start to normalize policy back to a less restrictive stance [ed. Ha!], but we don’t have to do that in a hurry”. It’s nice to be vindicated. But now what? Read more →

Thoughts From The Divide: The Harvest

BY JON WEBB
Even in times of turmoil (see President Lincoln’s Thanksgiving Day Proclamation), fall is a time to give thanks. And what should we be more thankful for than the gift of shopping? Retail sales reflected “continued resilience in the American consumer” and one might think recent Fed surveys are indicative of a new sense of optimism? The Empire Fed Manufacturing Survey’s headline index “shot up forty-three points to 31.2, its highest reading in nearly three years, and the six-month outlook showed that “firms remained optimistic about future conditions”. The Philadelphia Fed survey was not quite as ebullient in its reading of the current environment, the headline index dropping from 10.3 to -5.5 (a section headline drily noting “Most Current Indicators Soften”), but, on balance, the sense of optimism was palpable and mirrored the Empire Fed, (“Most Future Indicators Rise”) with the future activity jumping “from 36.7 to 56.6 in November, its highest level since June 2021”. Read more →

MI2 Partners: Thoughts From The Divide: Blame Game – 11th April

BY JON WEBB
While many love rollercoasters, the consensus in the office is that we have aged out, proving that you really can’t please all of the people all of the time. And so it was with “Liberation Day”. For market folk, the glass was clearly half-empty and investors seemed conflicted about their “liberation”: from close April 2nd to close April 8th, the S&P500 fell around 12%. Scott Bessent seemed nonplussed, repeating some stats about the distribution of stock ownership among Americans (hint: 50% of people don’t have any). It turns out the Tree of Liberty doesn’t only need periodic infusions of the blood of patriots and tyrants: it also swallows 401k gains. Read more →
Back to all posts →